Journal of Research in Medical Sciences, Vol 16, No 3 (2011)
Hamid Kalantari, Zahra Shahshahan, Mehdi Hejazi, Taghi Ghafghazi, Vahid Sebghatolahi
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Silymarin derived from silybum marianum (milk thistle), a flowering member of the daisy family, may benefit liver function in people infected with the hepatitis C virus. The aims of this pilot study were to assess the efficacy and safety of silymarin on serum hepatitis C virus (HCV) RNA, serum aminotransferases (ALT, AST) levels, liver fibrosis and well-being in patients with chronic hepatitis C (CHC).
METHODS: This prospective self-controlled trial study was conducted from March to September 2006 at Department of Gastroenterology, Isfahan University of Medical Sciences, Isfahan, Iran. 55 patients with HCV (10 female and 45 male) with a mean age of 31.8 ± 6.4 years (10-67 years) were participated in the study. Patients received 24 weeks of silymarin (630 mg/day). Baseline virological biochemical, liver fibrosis (by a serum fibrosis markers, including YKL–40 and Hyaluronic acid), and SF-36 questionnaire were performed with biochemical tests repeated at the end of the treatment period.
RESULTS: There was statistically difference in mean of ALT (108.7 ± 86.6 vs 70.3 ± 57.7) before and after the treatment (p less then 0.001). The means of AST were 99.4 ± 139.7 and 59.7 ± 64.32 before and after the treatment with statistically differences (p = 0.004). After the treatment, nine patients were found with negative HCV-RNA (p = 0.004) and statistically significant improvement in results of liver fibrosis markers were found only in fibrosis group (p = 0.015). Quality of life was improved significantly (p < 0.001).
.
CONCLUSIONS: This study indicated that in patients with CHC performing silymarin (650 mg/day) for 6 months, improved serum HCV-RNA titer, serum aminotransferases (ALT, AST), hepatic fibrosis and patient’s quality of life. More future studies are warranted.
.
Hepatitis C is a major cause of liver -related morbidity and mortality.1,2 Ribavirin plus interferon combination therapy, is presently considered the optimal treatment for patients with chronic hepatitis C, but the recommended treatment regimen is associated with considerable expense, adverse effects and poor efficacy in some patients with hepatitis C. Therefore, many hepatitis C patients use the herb silymarin (milk thistle), an alternative therapy for hepatitis C, in addition to or instead of standard treatment for chronic hepatitis C virus infection.3
Although the popularity of silymarin has been increased in people with liver disease4,5 but a little evidences with controversial results exist in effect of silaymarin on chronic hepatitis C.
In one study in Egypt,6 a dose of 420mg/day of silymarin has been used for one year. The quality of life of the patients improved very well, but the level of liver enzyme did not change.
An exhaustive search strategy identified 148 papers that studied silymarin compounds in liver disease. Of these, four trials included patients with hepatitis C which only two trials reported a decrease in serum transaminases.7,8 According to existence of little evidences with controversial results and increasing popularity of using silymarin in chronic hepatitis C, this study was conducted to evaluate the effect of higher doses of silymarin (630 mg/day) for 6 months, on patients with hepatitis C along with liver biopsy.
Methods
This prospective self-controlled trial study was conducted from March 2006 to September 2006 at Department of Gastroenterology, IsfahanUniversity of Medical Sciences, Isfahan, Iran.
Inclusion criteria contained confirmed chronic hepatitis C (HCV Ab (+), HCV-RNA[with PCR] (+)), normal or increased liver enzymes(ALT and AST) and not using interferon or ribavirin due to patient sensitivity or not consenting.
The pregnant patients and patients with side effect which confirmed with rechallenge test were excluded. The ethics committee of Isfahan University of Medical Sciences approved the study and all of participants signed an inform consent after explaining the aims and protocol of the study tot hem. The study was registered at Clinical-Trials.gov (Identifier: NCT01292161).
After measuring the baseline outcomes, we performed 630 mg/day silymarin a product of Goldaru pharmaceutical Co. Isfahan, Iran for six months. Following serum components were measured before and after the treatment:liver enzymes (ALT and AST), HCV-RNA(with PCR) and markers for liver fibrosis such as YKL 40 and Hyaluronic Acid (HA). YKL 40 was measured with YKL 40–EIA Kit, Quaildelcomp. San Diego. CA. with cut off value of284.8 ng/ml (sensitivity 80% and specificity71%) 9 and HA was assessed by enzyme linked binding protein assay (corgenix inc Denver) with the cut-off value of 110 mg/l (sensitivity 79.2% and specificity 89.4%).10
According to liver fibrosis markers (YKL 40 and HA) results before treatment,
patients were divided into three stages:Fibrosis group: YKL 40 > 150 ng/ml and HA >60 ng/ml or YKL 40 > 150 ng/ml or HA > 100ng/ml; Non-fibrosis group: YKL 40 <> 100 ng/ml or HA > 50 ng/ml more than the level before treatment. Fibrosis activity regression group: YKL 40 decreased more than 75 mg/ml or HA decreased ≥ 30ng/ml compared with before treatment levels. Fibrosis stable group: the level of liver fibrosis markers were not agreed with above level after treatment. For the determination of quality of life, we used the Iranian version of short form healthy survey (SF-36) questionnaire 11 before and after treatment which it’s validity and reliability was established.
The SF-36 questionnaire is a generic measure of health that is used to measure quality of life. It consists of 36 questions (items) which altogether score from 0 to 100. Data were analyzed with the paired t-test, McNemar, and chi–quare statistical methods. All analysis were done with SPSS v.16.
Results
Seventy seven patients were enrolled in the study. One patient died and 21 patients did not participate in follow-up process. Finally, 55 patients (10 female and 45 male) with the means age of 31.8 } 6.4 years (10-67 years) completed the study. The mean of ALT before and after the treatmentwere 108.7 } 86.6 and 70.3 } 57.7.
According to paired t-test analysis there was a statistical difference before and after the treatment with silymarin (p < 0.001). The mean of AST were 99.4 } 139.7 and 59.7 } 64.32 before and after the treatment. According to paired t-test analysis there was statistically different from before the treatment with silymarin (p = 0.004).
After the treatment, nine patients were found with negative HCV-RNA which in regard to McNemar test, it was significantly difference before and after the treatment (p = 0.004). The results of liver fibrosis markers are showed in table 1. According to hi-square method,there was a statistical improvement only in fibrosis group (p = 0.015). .
.
Click Here To View Table 1. and PDF File
..
The means of SF-36 score were 51.06 ・} 21.8and 61.49 ・} 22.8 before and after the treatment respectively. According to paired t-test analysis,there was a statistical improvement in quality of life of patients (p less then 0.001).
.
Discussion
Silymarin has been claimed to have a beneficial effect on various types of liver injury, including alcoholic liver disease, drug and toxin induced hepatotoxicity, and acute and chronic viral hepatitis.8
Our results showed that performing silymarin was significantly improved the serum liver enzymes, HCV-RNA titer, hepatic fibrosis and patient’s quality of life.
The mechanism of silymarin might be by protecting liver cell injury with free radical scavenging, stabilization of liver cell membranes, stimulation of hepatocyte protein synthesis, and modulation of the immune response.12
Also recently determined silymarin had antiviral effects against hepatitis C virus cell culture infection that included inhibition of virus entry, RNA and protein expression, and infectious virus production.13
There is a little evidence for using this drug for hepatitis C. Previous studies8,14 have reported an improvement in a number of liver chemistries, including ALT, following treatment with S. marianum and our results supported their findings.
Tanamly et al in adouble-blinded trial evaluated silymarin in preventing complications of chronic hepatitis C. Although they showed an improvement in patient’s symptoms and quality of life, but no significantly improvement in their liver enzymes, liver fibrosis markers and HCV-RNA was achieved.
Our results were not agreed with their findings respectively. The difference might be because of the performed dose of silymarin,the study design and the genotypes of patients.6 Gordon et al in a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, crossover study examined the effects of silybum marianum on patients with chronic hepatitis C and showed no significanteffect on serum HCV-RNA, alanine aminotransferaselevels, quality of life or psychological well-being.7
Our findings did not support their findings respectively. It may be due to their low sample size or study design which may influence the results.
Adverse drug effects related to silymarin have been published in studies and case reports involving a total of over 7000 patients and those confirmed that it is safe, with only three reports of significant adverse reactions.5-12,14-18 Thus, it seems from the current data that patients with chronic hepatitis C are to benefit from taking salymarin.
Conclusions
This study indicated that in patients with chronic hepatitis C performing silymarin (650mg/day) for 6 months, improved serum HCVRNAtiter, serum aminotransferases (ALT,AST), hepatic fibrosis and patient’s quality of life. More future studies are warranted.
Acknowledgments
This research was supported by a grant (Grant
No. 83451) from the research council of Isfahan
University of Medical Sciences. The authors acknowledge
the kind assistance and financial
support provided by the Vice Chancellor for
Research at the Isfahan University of Medical
Sciences.
Conflict of Interests
Authors have no conflict of interests.
Authors' Contributions>HK carried out the design and coordinated the study, participated in most of the experiments and
prepared the manuscript. ZSH and TGH provide assistance in the design of the study, coordinated
and carried out all the experiments and participated in manuscript preparation. MH and VS provided
assistance for all experiments. All authors have read and approved the content of the manuscript.
References
1. Kalantari H, Kazemi F, Minakari M. Efficacy of triple therapy with interferon alpha-2b, ribavirin and amantadine in
the treatment of naïve patients with chronic hepatitis C. J Res Med Sci 2007; 12(4): 178-85.
2. Kalantari H, Rad N. Efficacy of Interferon alpha-2b with or without Ribavirin in thalassemia major patients with
chronic hepatitis C virus infection: a randomized, doubleblind, controlled, parallel group trial. J Res Med Sci 2010;
15(6): 310-6.
3. Luper S. A review of plants used in the treatment of liver disease: part 1. Altern Med Rev 1998; 3(6): 410-21 .
4. Mayer KE, Myers RP, Lee SS. Silymarin treatment of viral hepatitis: a systematic review. J Viral Hepat 2005;
12(6): 559-67.
5. Salmi HA, Sarna S. Effect of silymarin on chemical, functional, and morphological alterations of the liver. A
double-blind controlled study. Scand J Gastroenterol 1982; 17(4): 517-21.
6. Tanamly MD, Tadros F, Labeeb S, Makld H, Shehata M, Mikhail N, et al. Randomised double-blinded trial evaluating>silymarin for chronic hepatitis C in an Egyptian village: study description and 12-month results. Dig Liver Dis
2004; 36(11): 752-9.
7. Gordon A, Hobbs DA, Bowden DS, Bailey MJ, Mitchell J, Francis AJ, et al. Effects of Silybum marianum on serum
hepatitis C virus RNA, alanine aminotransferase levels and well-being in patients with chronic hepatitis C. J Gastroenterol>Hepatol 2006; 21(1 Pt 2): 275-80.
8. Buzzelli G, Moscarella S, Giusti A, Duchini A, Marena C, Lampertico M. A pilot study on the liver protective effect
of silybinphosphatiylcholine Complex (Idb1016) in chronic active hepatitis. Int J Clin Pharmacol Ther Toxicol
1993; 31(9): 456-60.
9. Johansen JS, Christoffersen P, Møller S, Price PA, Henriksen JH, Garbarsch C, et al. Serum YKL-40 is increased in
patients with hepatic fibrosis. J Hepatol 2000; 32(6): 911-20.
10.Guéchot J, Laudat A, Loria A, Serfaty L, Poupon R, Giboudeau J. Diagnostic accuracy of hyaluronan and type III>procollagen amino-terminal peptide serum assays as markers of liver fibrosis in chronic viral hepatitis C evaluated
by ROC curve analysis. Clin Chem 1996; 42(4): 558-63.
11.Montazeri A, Goshtasebi A, Vahdaninia M, Gandek B. The Short Form Health Survey (SF-36): translation and validation
study of the Iranian version. Qual Life Res 2005; 14(3): 875-82.
12.Mira L, Silva M, Manso CF. Scavenging of reactive oxygen species by silibinin dihemisuccinate. Biochem Pharmacol
1994; 48(4): 753-9.
13.Wagoner J, Negash A, Kane OJ, Martinez LE, Nahmias Y, Bourne N, et al. Multiple effects of silymarin on the hepatitis
C virus lifecycle. Hepatology 2010; 51(6): 1912-21.
14.Afdhal NH. Diagnosing fibrosis in hepatitis C: is the pendulum swinging from biopsy to blood tests? Hepatology
2003; 37(5): 972-4.
15.Martines G, Piva M, Copponi V, Cagnetta G. Silymarin in pregnancy and during hormonal contraceptive treatment.
Blood chemistry and ultrastructural findings in the experimental model. Arch Sci Med (Torino) 1979; 136(3): 443-54.
(Italian).
16.Geier J, Fuchs T, Wahl R. Anaphylactic shock due to an extract of Silybum marianum in a patient with immediatetype
allergy to kiwi fruit. Allergologie 1990; 13(10): 387-8.
17.Mironets VI, Krasovskaia EA, Polishchuk II. A case of urticaria during carsil treatment. Vrachebnoe Delo 1990; (7):
86-7. (Russian).
18.An adverse reaction to the herbal medication milk thistle (Silybum marianum). Adverse Drug Reactions Advisory
Committee. Med J Aust 1999; 170(5): 218-9.
No comments:
Post a Comment